Quick Comparison Table
Hi-Lift Jack PP-300 |
Maasdam A20 |
Tuf-Tug |
ATE Tools |
Tekton 5542 | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
|
| Price | $ | $ | $ | $ | $ |
| Weight | 19.9 pounds. | 7.9 pounds. | Not specified. | 15.9 pounds. | 6.6 pounds. |
| Dimensions | 40.4 x 5.9 x 5.5 inches. | 3.8 x 29 x 5 inches. | Not specified. | Not specified. | 26.2 x 3.2 x 5.5 inches. |
| Stump Diameter/pull limit | 5000 pounds. | ¾ of a ton. | 2500 pound capacity with a 20 foot reach on a single line. 5000 pound capacity with a 10 foot reach on a double line. | 5 tons. | 2000 pounds. |
| Amazon FREE Shipping |  |
|
|
|
|
 |
 |
|
|
|
|
How to Select the Best Tree Stump Puller?
Tree stump pullers come in many different forms. In fact, if it pulls a stump, it can essentially be called a stump puller. However, it can be difficult to find the best stump puller for the money.
This is because users have to make sure the stump-to-puller ratio is correct. Within this buying guide we aim to show you several different stump puller options for both professionals and home users.
Many of these may be suitable for the stump you’re looking to pull, or they might not be. It pays to review all stump pullers very carefully in order to ascertain whether this particular stump removal method is the right one for you.
Work Type
When a tree is cut down, the stump left behind doesn’t conform to any particular size or shape. In fact, you won’t find two stumps that look the same. That is why stump removal with a stump puller can be a particularly difficult task.
You need to take stock of all the different tree stumps you have for removal, and this can help you determine the type of tree stump puller that will suit your needs.
Safety
Removing a tree stump safely takes a lot of planning. Often, people use a tree stump harness attached to a vehicle or a machine to slowly pull the stump from the earth.
However, if you go too fast, the stump can fly through the air. If you go too slow, the process might take a while. When you’re removing a stump, you need to make sure there are several people helping you do it.
This can be helpful if the stump removal process goes wrong.
Efficiency
The efficiency of the stump pulling device depends on what it’s made out of and its pull limit. Some stump pullers are only suitable for small backyard tree stumps, therefore they have a breaking point.
Others are more suitable for commercial or industrial settings and these generally have a much higher pull limit. Check out the products within our buying guide to see which is going to be the most efficient for your tree stump pulling operation.
Features
Features vary for each tree stump puller, depending on the make, model or manufacturer. In some cases, a winding rope and cable is connected to a revolving cylinder within a tripod setup.
This can be powered by an engine or with levers. In other cases, the tree stump puller features a harness which can be attached to a vehicle such as a truck or tractor.
Maintenance
Maintenance of tree stump pullers is generally very easy. In the case of tree stump pullers which require manual labor, harnesses should be checked for rust, imperfections, rips and tears.
If the stump remover is engine-powered within a tripod setup, you should check the oil and fuel levels.
Regardless of the tree stump pulling product, you should always make sure it’s free from any broken parts that could cause the operation to become unsafe.
Budget
In order to get the best stump puller for the money, you should consider how much manual labor you are willing to do. Often, the price tag can be reflective of how much energy the operator has to put in.
For something that’s engine powered, you can expect to spend over $1000. For harnesses and manual pullers, they are for sale from around $30.
Don’t let the cost put you off. Tree stump pulling is an effective method at removing a tree stump, rather than waiting for it to rot away in your yard
Top 5 Tree Stump Pullers Reviews
1
Hi-Lift Jack PP-300
Pros & Cons
Pros:
- It’s a clean approach to stump removal.
- It’s a very affordable product.
- It can remove metal poles as well as tree stumps.
Cons:
- It can only remove small tree stumps.
- It doesn’t come with the chain necessary to remove stumps.
What’s included
- Hi-Lift Jack.
Specs
- Weight: 19.9 pounds.
- Dimensions: 40.4 x 5.9 x 5.5 inches.
- Stump Diameter/pull limit: 5000 pounds.
FAQ
QWhere is it made? ABloomfield, Indiana.
QWhat is the post puller made out of? A1 ½ inch thick square steel tubing.
Overview
Feedback about the Hi-Lift Jack has been exceptional. It’s durable, hardy and can remove small tree stumps with ease. Although it’s not suitable for larger tree stumps, it still has a pull capacity of up to 5000 pounds. This makes it useful for not only tree stumps, but fencing as well. For the cost, it represents good buying and is easily one of the best tree stump pullers for the money.
Reviews
Check out what other people who purchased this product think about it. Read Hi-Lift Jack PP-300 tree stump puller reviews.
2
Maasdam A20
Pros & Cons
Pros:
- It can pull up to ¾ of a ton.
- It has a long and flexible reach.
- It’s relatively affordable.
Cons:
- The rope can sometimes slip under heavy loads.
- It can be very labor-intensive to crank the lever.
What’s included
- Long Haul Rope Puller.
- 20 inches of rope.
Specs
- Weight: 7.9 pounds.
- Dimensions: 3.8 x 29 x 5 inches.
- Stump Diameter/pull limit: ¾ of a ton.
FAQ
QHow much rope comes with this tree stump puller? A20 feet.
QWhat is the limit on the rope length? AAny length of rope can be used.
Overview
If you’re not scared of a little hard work, this stump puller will help you on your way to a stump-free backyard. It’s powerful, durable and can provide up to ¾ of a ton of pulling power to lift small and large stumps.
It’s also easy to assemble and even offers the option of using a longer rope, rather than the three-strand 20 foot rope supplied. Overall, it’s top rated on the market and is one of the best tree stump pullers on the market.
Reviews
Check out what other people who purchased this product think about it. Read Maasdam A20t Tree stump puller reviews.
3
Tuf-Tug
Pros & Cons
Pros:
- It has a dual ratchet drive design for versatility depending on the stump you’re pulling.
- It’s made of solid steel.
- The cable winds smoothly.
- It requires less manual labor than other similar products on the market.
Cons:
- It’s quite expensive in comparison to other similar products on the market.
- The engaging and disengaging mechanism isn’t as strong as it looks, some users note.
What’s included
- Tuf-Tug Dual Capacity Cable Hoist/Puller.
Specs
- Stump Diameter/pull limit: 2500 pound capacity with a 20 foot reach on a single line. 5000 pound capacity with a 10 foot reach on a double line.
FAQ
QCan you lower the load slowly, notch by notch? AYes.
QWhat is the cable diameter? A¼ inches.
Overview
It can sometimes be difficult to find a heavy-duty stump remover that you know will handle those larger jobs. The reason this product is top rated is because it can handle those larger jobs, and more. It has a dual capacity of 2500 pounds and 5000 pounds – perfect for those larger stump pulling operations.
Although it’s a lot more expensive than other similar pullers on the market, it’s well worth the cost. You could almost certainly get a better deal if you buy online, as well. It’s durable, hardy and will keep pulling as long as you want it to. It’s easy to see it’s one of the best tree stump
Reviews
Check out what other people who purchased this product think about it. Read Tuf-Tug tree stump puller reviews.
4
ATE Tools
Pros & Cons
Pros:
- It has a high leverage ratio which makes it easier to operate.
- It’s very affordable.
- It has an automatic let-down safety catch for the operator’s peace of mind.
Cons:
- The cable is too short for a range of jobs.
- The instructions for use aren’t very clear.
What’s included
- ATE Tools Puller.
Specs
- Weight: 15.9 pounds.
- Stump Diameter/pull limit: 5 tons.
FAQ
QWhere is it made? AChina.
QWhat can it do other than pull stumps? AIt can pull heavy machinery and equipment, free stuck vehicles, hoist objects and even tighten fences.
Overview
Although functional and durable, this ATE Tools Puller has its downfalls. The cable is just too short for many pulling activities. Even though it’s for sale at a very affordable price, users must make sure the cable is long enough for the stump they are looking to pull out.
Reviews
Check out what other people who purchased this product think about it. Read ATE Tools tree stump puller reviews.
5
Tekton 5542
Pros & Cons
Pros:
- It’s durable with a corrosion-resistant galvanized finish.
- It’s well priced.
- It has a very strong cable.
- The ratchet handle is padded for added comfort.
Cons:
- It’s best suited to smaller tree stumps unless you dig the stump up.
- Its pull limit is less than other similar products made with weaker components.
What’s included
- Tekton Dual Gear Power Puller.
Specs
- Weight: 6.6 pounds.
- Dimensions: 26.2 x 3.2 x 5.5 inches.
- Stump Diameter/pull limit: 2000 pounds.
FAQ
QHow far does it extend? A12 feet.
QHow easy is it to pull stumps out with? AIt’s relatively easy if the stumps are smaller than 8 inches. Any bigger and the operator will need to dig the stump and cut major roots while pulling.
Overview
Not all tree stump pullers are created equal, that’s why it’s important you review each product to ensure it’s fit for purpose. However, this puller certainly meets the mark when it comes to durability, price, versatility and ease of use. For these reasons, it’s top rated on the market and is one of the best stump pullers for the money.
Reviews
Check out what other people who purchased this product think about it. Read Tekton 5542 tree stump puller reviews.
Where to Buy Tree Stump Pullers?
When you’re looking to buy an affordable and top rated tree stump puller, there are many places to look. Firstly, you can often get the best deal when you buy online. Amazon offers so many tree stump pullers at highly competitive prices. Otherwise, you can shop around in your local area to see what hardware stores can offer.
Leading Tree Stump Puller Brands and Manufacturers
- Hi-Lift Jack
- Tuf-Tug
- Tekton
- Maasdam
Related Guides